Errors in Multiphysics Integration (Heat Transfer, Fluid Flow, Electrochemistry, etc.)

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Hi everyone,

I’m new to COMSOL and am working on integrating heat transfer, fluid flow, electrochemistry, and porous media for my project. However, I’m encountering the following errors:

Failed to evaluate initial residual for segregated step 4. Division by zero. Function: / Failed to evaluate variable. Variable: comp1.spf.ct_here Defined as: ((36nojac(down((comp1.spf.mu+comp1.spf.muT)/comp1.spf.epsilon_p)))comp1.spf.meshVol)/comp1.spf.meshVolInt Failed to evaluate variable. Variable: comp1.spf.sigma_dg_ns Defined as: 4comp1.spf.ct_here Failed to evaluate expression. Expression: dvol_spatial(comp1.spf.KStressn_avy-(comp1.spf.ujumpycomp1.spf.sigma_dg_ns)) Failed to evaluate Jacobian of expression. Expression: (comp1.spf.KStressn_avxtest(comp1.spf.ut_herex)+comp1.spf.KStressn_avytest(comp1.spf.ut_herey)+comp1.spf.KStressn_avztest(comp1.spf.ut_herez)+comp1.spf.KStressTestn_avxcomp1.spf.ujumpx+comp1.spf.KStressTestn_avycomp1.spf.ujumpy+comp1.spf.KStressTestn_avzcomp1.spf.ujumpz-comp1.spf.sigma_dg_nscomp1.spf.ujumpxtest(comp1.spf.ut_herex)-comp1.spf.sigma_dg_nscomp1.spf.ujumpytest(comp1.spf.ut_herey)-comp1.spf.sigma_dg_nscomp1.spf.ujumpztest(comp1.spf.ut_herez))(dvol_spatial) Does anyone have any insights on how to address these issues? Any help would be greatly appreciated!

Thanks!


2 Replies Last Post Sep 16, 2024, 8:52 p.m. EDT
Robert Koslover Certified Consultant

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 2 months ago Sep 14, 2024, 10:06 p.m. EDT

Sounds like you have one or more errors in your setup and specification of the problem. Note that it is prudent to prepare simple single-physics models first, before attempting those that combine many kinds of physics, as the latter is both more likely to fail and be more difficult to debug. Regardless, the full details and causes of an error condition can only occasionally be understood by inspection of a Comsol software-generated error message(s) in isolation. I encourage you to post your .mph file to the forum, so that it can be reviewed by others here, and so that the issue(s) in your particular model will be easier to identify.

-------------------
Scientific Applications & Research Associates (SARA) Inc.
www.comsol.com/partners-consultants/certified-consultants/sara
Sounds like you have one or more errors in your setup and specification of the problem. Note that it is prudent to prepare simple single-physics models first, before attempting those that combine many kinds of physics, as the latter is both more likely to fail and be more difficult to debug. Regardless, the full details and causes of an error condition can only occasionally be understood by inspection of a Comsol software-generated error message(s) in isolation. I encourage you to post your .mph file to the forum, so that it can be reviewed by others here, and so that the issue(s) in your particular model will be easier to identify.

Please login with a confirmed email address before reporting spam

Posted: 2 months ago Sep 16, 2024, 8:52 p.m. EDT

From time to time when setting up a new problem I see this sort of error message. I translate it as "something isn't right." A systematic approach (say turning off some multiphysics interactions) is needed. It may be advisable to set up a problem in a simple geometry first.

From time to time when setting up a new problem I see this sort of error message. I translate it as "something isn't right." A systematic approach (say turning off some multiphysics interactions) is needed. It may be advisable to set up a problem in a simple geometry first.

Reply

Please read the discussion forum rules before posting.

Please log in to post a reply.

Note that while COMSOL employees may participate in the discussion forum, COMSOL® software users who are on-subscription should submit their questions via the Support Center for a more comprehensive response from the Technical Support team.